Home
  Message Board
  Atari Systems
  Game Scores
  Video Reviews
  Bonus Material
  Join TAT!
  Contact

UserName:
Password:
 

Mean 18 - The Atari Times

Mean 18


The Cruelest Game
by David Sherwin

June 19, 2004
Accolade was one of the better American software houses of the late 1980s, and they produced a wide array of quality titles for a number of computer systems, such as Hardball, an entertaining baseball game, Fight Night, which still has its fans, and Mean 18, which attempted to cash in on the popular success of the Leaderboard series of golf games by Access. Fight Night and Hardball were ported by Accolade to the XE, and Atari re-released them both on cartridge for the XEGS. Mean 18 didn't quite make it out the door, and it was presumed lost when Atari closed shop in 1996. Fortunately, a few copies of what appear to be an "almost-complete" port surfaced a few years ago, and they've now been reproduced for general distribution by Sunmark. Those looking for another quality sports simulation are, however, advised to look elsewhere: Mean 18 is, its present form, very demo-ish and it is severely compromised in gameplay and its graphic environment.

Gameplay

Computer golf games have historically been divided into two groups: overly fussy, technical simulations that present too many options for club choice and wind direction, and are consequently not fun to play, and arcade games that are too simplistic for hardcore golf enthusiasts, but relatively easy to use and learn. Mean 18 intrepidly attempts to bridge the very large gap between these two worlds...and falls flat on its face doing it. Some elements of play are easier than others, but the overall game interface tends to be cumbersome and awkward; I certainly didn't want to return for another round after testing these greens.

Mean 18 presents a standard 18-hole golf game, which is certainly sufficient for all but the most diehard golf fanatic. There are apparently several courses, but I could not choose any option beyond the standard "Pebble Beach" course. It's difficult to believe, in any case (and given the poor quality of the main attraction), that any of these other courses could possibly offer anything of interest to the average gamer.

Mean 18 is best compared in gameplay to its popular predecessor, Leaderboard Golf, and features most of the traps, hazards, and features of that game. Unlike Leaderboard, however, the "options" menu is extremely clumsy, and it's very difficult to change clubs to adapt to the unique conditions of each hole. I gave up in frustration after the third hole and stuck with one club for everything, with predictable impact on my overall gaming score.

A scorecard reflects results at the end of the game, but few will likely have the fortitude to reach that erstwhile humble goal.

Graphics

With its clever overhead and multidirectional perspectives, and in-game "zoom" features, it's clear that Mean 18 was Atari's attempt to introduce innovative and advanced graphics displays into an XE sports game. Something surely went terribly wrong in development, however, because Mean 18 has been left with the ugliest gaming environment ever seen in an XE game.

Nothing in this game's graphical environment really seems right. The colour palette is excruciatingly bad, the graphics are blocky and ugly, and the "zoom" feature is jerky and unpleasant to use. All of these problems are, however, minor flaws in comparison with the game's biggest glitch: all screens are individually drawn in Mean 18, and it takes the game an eternity to plot each one. Leaderboard Golf also suffers to some extent from this problem, but that game is lightning-quick in comparison with the slug-like plotting of this game. I actually had time to walk to my kitchen, pour myself a drink, and walk back to the computer before the computer finished drawing one hole late in my first game. It's an infuriating, hair-pulling, head-beating-against-the-wall flaw that will dissuade all but the most patient -- or masochistic -- from completing a game.

Sound

Golf is not supposed to be a loud game, and the lack of sound effects, in-game music, or other auditory nonsense is most welcome. It's certainly the best feature of this otherwise grating and unpleasant game.

Summary

Sunmark deserves much credit for dredging up this one from the lost depths of the Tramiel vaults and making it available to 8-bit enthusiasts everywhere. Sunmark deserves even more credit for packaging Mean 18 with MIDIMaze, enabling players to acquire this gaming dog as a free bonus for purchasing a truly extraordinary and revolutionary game (MIDIMaze). Mean 18 truly lives up to its title: it's a punishing, brutal title that probably would have tanked upon release. Among Atari's many questionable policies in the late '80s, it seems as if their decision not to give this stinker a commercial release was one of their soundest.

(64K, joystick required. Approx. $40 from Sunmark as bonus to MIDIMaze)



Well, the title screen looks promising.
This doesn't look so bad.
It sure is hard to hit the hole from this far out.
Mean 18
System: 8-Bit
Publisher: Atari
Genre: Sports
Graphics Score: 20%
Sound & Music Score: 50%
Gameplay Score: 40%
Control Score: 25%

Final Score: 30%



Reader Comments for Mean 18

Add Comment
Name:
Subject:
Comment:
Check:
What is the greatest video game company of all time? (Hint: Atari.)